Books in French are on www.livres-cinema.info
Revolution in Paradise
Veiled Representations of Jewish Characters in the Cinema of Occupied France
(0 vote)Average rating:
| 0 | rating |  = We can do without |
| 0 | rating |  = Good book |
| 0 | rating |  = Excellent book |
| 0 | rating |  = Unique / a reference |
Your rating: -
Book Presentation:
The era of the German Occupation of France constituted, surprisingly, a golden age for the arts. These works of art seem to be devoid of political impact. The purpose of this book is to show that, contrary to this accepted view, some of these films were intimately linked to the political situation. All five movies analyzed (Les Inconnus dans la maison;, dir. Henri Decoin, 1942; Les Visiteurs du Soir;, dir. Marcel Carn, 1942; L'Eternel retour;, dir. Jean Delannoy, 1943; Les Enfants du Paradis;, dir. Marcel Carn, 1943) present characters not identified as Jews but who exhibit negative "Jewish" traits, in contrast to the aristocratic characters whom they aspire to emulate. They demonstrate, implicitly, central themes of explicit anti-Semitic propaganda. Analysis of these films brings out the contradictory nature of European anti-Semitism. On one hand, the Jew is the anti-Christ, throttling the world with disgusting materialism while on the other hand, he is representative of an ancestral stifling morality, which it is time to abolish.
About the Author:
Yehuda (Jean-Bernard) Moraly is an associate professor at the Hebrew University, Jerusalem. His fields of research are mainly French theatre and film: Jean Genet, la vie écrite (Editions de la Différence, 1988); Claudel metteur en scène (Presses Universitaires de Franche Comté, 1998); Le Maître fou, Genet théoricien du théâtre, (Nizet, 2009). His L'œuvre impossible: Claudel, Genet, Fellini (Le Manuscrit, 2013) deals mostly with Fellini’s cinema. He is also a playwright and his plays are published and produced in France and Israel.
Press Reviews:
Revolution in Paradise is a strange mixture. Moraly has an enviably deep knowledge of cinema, and his fluency with the films of the period, meticulously researched from genesis to finished product, and beyond, since films were edited beyond their original release, can only evoke praise. He is also a very talented writer, revealing his own creative abilities, weaving myriad of pointilist detailsincluding the amount of food promised to a film doginto a highly informative whole, while raising significant questions about art and politics. But to reprise the original metaphor of the detective story, real life does not have the systematicity of a plot in which all the facts lead inevitably to one grand conclusion. This is the major flaw of an otherwise impressive book. Annette Aronowicz, Historical Journal of Film, Radio and Television, 2021 Vol. 41, No. 3, 578639
'An in-depth look at the world of French filmmaking during the German Occupation (1940?44), this study seeks to demonstrate how extensively anti-Semitic prejudice permeated not only French society as a whole at the time of the Nazi takeover but also the mentalities and actions of film producers, directors, screenwriters, and actors.'
James P. Gilroy, University of Denver
'The golden age of French cinema which paradoxically sees its peak during years of occupation takes on a whole new meaning in Moraly?s study. In this, she deserves attention. Indeed, in a very well-documented work, Moraly puts profoundly question the assumption that the golden age of French cinema has constituted a space of freedom.'
Translated from French: 'L?âge d?or du cinéma français qui voit paradoxalement son apogée durant les années d?occupation prend dans l?étude de Moraly un tout autre sens. En cela, elle mérite l?attention. En effet, dans un ouvrage très bien documenté, Moraly remet profondément en question l?hypothèse selon laquelle l?âge d?or du cinéma français a constitué un espace de liberté.'
Éric Touya, Dalhousie French Studies
'This high-minded book gives scholars of French artistic activity during the German Occupation much to consider and debate, especially regarding the methodological issue of how the slippery relations of perceived context, text, and subtext feed into our ability to proffer retrospective ethical assessments.'
Edward Baron Turk, Holocaust and Genocide Studies
'The book is rich in information on the films of the time (some of which are only accessible in the archives or have been destroyed), on the biography and testimonies of the authors and actors, and on the reception of the works ... Jean Paul Sartre said in 1946 that the playwright's task was to "forge myths". This imperative is also valid for the filmmaker. However, there are myths that bring life and myths that kill. Moraly's book teaches us this tragic and terrifying truth that these two categories of myths are often mixed up.'
Thierry Alcoloumbre, Journal of Religion and Film
'Revolution in Paradise performs an important task.'
Sara Jo Ben Zvi, Segula: The Jewish History Magazine
'This brilliant academic study includes an outstanding index and will be invaluable to students and researchers. [...] All concerned in today?s culture clashes should note its far-reaching conclusion.'
David Isaacson, The Jerusalem Post
"This audacious and engaging study has the potential to revolutionize our thinking about the invisible antisemitic underpinnings of the much-celebrated films of Occupation France? Moraly?s extraordinary prism of awareness? does not succumb to finger-pointing and challenging; rather he demonstrates an extremely nuanced understanding of the history of cultural symbolism and how it works cinematically. Avoiding Manicheanism while maintaining his deep love of the cinema and its histories, he performs a textual reading of great subtlety and imagination that brings to light a subject that has been hidden for years? its conclusions expand over social history and across time." Sandy Flitterman-Lewis, Cineaste
See the publisher website: Liverpool University Press
> On a related topic:
Continental Films (2022)
French Cinema Under German Control
by Christine Leteux and Bertrand Taverneir
Subject: History of Cinema
Hollywood Hates Hitler! (2020)
Jew-Baiting, Anti-Nazism, and the Senate Investigation Into Warmongering in Motion Pictures
Subject: History of Cinema
Promises of Citizenship (2019)
Film Recruitment of African Americans in World War II
Subject: History of Cinema
Hollywood Goes to War (1990)
How Politics, Profits and Propaganda Shaped World War II Movies
by Clayton R. Koppes and Gregory D. Black
Subject: History of Cinema
Cinema of Paradox (1985)
French Filmmaking Under the German Occupation
Reframing Remembrance (2021)
Contemporary French Cinema and the Second World War
Back
